Thursday, 23 August 2007

"...That We Might Be Made God?!"

by Paul Kerr

March 1, 1998

Mr. Kerry S. Robichaux
Living Stream Ministry
1853 West Ball Road
Anaheim, CA 92804

RE: Article titled: "...That We Might Be Made God" appearing in Affirmation & Critique Vol. 1, Number 3, published by Living Stream Ministry, Anaheim, California

Dear Kerry,

While perusing the Internet I unfortunately stumbled upon your above mentioned article. That you chose for your title a partial sentence from Athanasius' De Incartione, speaks volumes. I only wonder why you waited for the last third of your piece, to finally admit that indeed the Bible does not teach that "man becomes God"?
The methodology you employ in structuring your "doctrinal" thesis is not entirely new but does offer a rather unusual variation. Most who use this method present their pet doctrine and then frantically scramble to find a few passages of Scripture to support it. You have brought this ad hoc approach to new heights! Not being deterred by lack of Biblical basis for your "man becomes God" notion, you simply resort to the extrascriptual non-canonical writings of the church "fathers", combing through them in a desperate attempt to find legitimization, all the while suggesting that Protestant theologians are somehow amiss for not doing so, and furthermore infer that these "church writings" are on the same level as Scripture.

Perhaps you are unaware that this approach to defining doctrine is justifiably discounted by most reputable non-Roman Catholic and non-Eastern Orthodox theologians of the evangelical Protestant sort, who recognize canonical Scripture as the standard authoritative measuring rod and only legitimate starting point of reference. Allow me to quote renowned theologian J.I. Packer who, I happily might add, is indeed Protestant, "Historic Protestantism...finds truth in the teaching of the canonical Scriptures as such. It receives these Scriptures as inspired, inerrant, sufficient (i.e., telling us ALL that God wills to tell us and all we need to know for salvation and eternal life), and clear (i.e. STRAIGHTFORWARD AND SELF-INTERPRETING ON ALL MATTERS OF IMPORTANCE). The first two positions (Catholicism and modernists) treat human judgements on the Bible as decisive for truth and wisdom; the third (referring to Protestantism) . . . systematically submits all human thoughts to Scripture which it takes seriously as canon." The method you use of presenting your pet doctrine of man becoming God, and providing fallible tradition as your authoritative basis, for obvious reasons is viewed with overt suspicion, especially on matters so non-essential yet controversial as man becoming God.

Furthermore, as implied by Packer, the Bible is instructive in what it does include AND what it does not include. Your admittance that the Bible does not teach that man becomes God leaves one to wonder why you do? Your rabid insistence on introducing this extrascriptual man becoming God "doctrine" into Christian circles and actually insinuating it is a crucial item of the faith is rather perplexing, as it serves no definable purpose and some would reasonably argue is grossly heretical. (An argument which you cleverly attempt to preempt by anticipating it the context of your article).

Since the notion of man becoming God is a proverbial Pandora's box, instead of criticizing Protestant theologians and so called "modern believers", you might do well to follow their wise example in keeping it closed. It is a minefield waiting to explode in the face of its proponents. I offer only two of the mines in a vast field of many:

1] You claim that your definition of man becoming God is not God as an object of worship or in certain aspects such as omnipresence, etc. Since man becoming God is not taught in the Bible who then is qualified to determine which aspects of God man becomes, and which aspects he is excluded from? You? The church "fathers"? Witness Lee? Your man becoming God "doctrine" implies the commodization of God and subsequent dissection of God into various parts. Some parts man becomes and some remain God alone. The God who indwells the believers is indeed omnipresent, or He could not indwell more than one believer at once. As this is the case, what happens to this part of God once I become Him?

2] In application, this man-becomes-God "doctrine" is especially insidious, as it provides the foundation for all manner of deviant teachings and practices to proliferate. This is especially evident in the so called "local churches" a.ka. "Lord's recovery", where this doctrine has been allowed to fester and evolve unchecked for the past few decades, quite naturally resulting in the following perfidious teachings being taught from the pulpit:
• "There is no need to pray about what to do; just follow the ministry."
• "We don't need to think, we just do what we are told."
• "Follow Witness Lee blindly. Even if he's wrong he's right."
• "Our burden is to pick up Brother Lee's teaching and way to make us all Witness Lees, like a Witness Lee duplication center."

and more recently in a letter by the full-timers at the conclusion of their training in Anaheim,

• "...we would also like to follow the trainers as the extensions of Brother Lee."

Of course, this perversion of the gospel is not too surprising as it merely represents the logical outcome and manifestation of the man-becoming-God doctrine - for if man becomes God, Witness Lee and his "extension" becomes God! It is a tiny baby step from here, over your imaginary line into the realm of blatant idolatrous man worship.

Furthermore, this man-becoming-God notion reeks of eastern mysticism. [As an aside, I find it interesting that two of your favorite "man becomes God" theorists, Athanasius and Clement, both hailed from Alexandria - a steamy hotbed of Oriental and Greek philosophies, along with every other strange teaching to appear over the horizon in ancient times.] In an era when New Age teachings are infiltrating every level of our Judeo-Christian society; when secular humanists are attacking the Church on a daily basis; with Buddhism and Hinduism gaining influence and large followings in the West; you have the brazen temerity to shamelessly disseminate this "man becomes God" concept dressed up in a Christian cloak of apparent respectability! That the apostles, by the Lord's wisdom and inspiration, did not teach that man becomes God, is not at all surprising, considering the dangerous perils and consequences associated with this matter. Since for good reason the authors of Scripture were notably cautious, one wonders why you acknowledge yet ignore this prudence and find it necessary to gleefully and with apparent abandonment join the recklessness of the church fathers by dogmatically promoting this non-canonical, extrascriptual, tradition based teaching. Considering it is a main tenet of Leeism, I suppose it is understandable that his zealous coworkers, a.k.a. his "extension", would attempt to mainstream the issue at any cost, even if it means using tradition and not Scripture as their authoritative basis.

Athanasius' usefulness during the first Council of Nice is well known - after all, they were not gathered to discuss man becoming God. However, regarding the writings of the church "fathers", I think Andrew Miller articulated it best in his Short Papers on Church History, "They may interest and instruct us but they cannot command our faith. This can only stand on the solid ground of the word of God, never on the infirm ground of tradition. 'Scripture stands alone,' as one has said, 'in majestic isolation, preeminent in instruction, and separated by unapproachable excellence from everything written by the church fathers ' . . . The definite and absolute statements of scriptures coming direct from God to the soul, are widely different from the writing of Ignatius and of all the church fathers. Our only sure and safe guide is the word of God. How seasonable then is the word in the First Epistle of John, 'Let that therefore abide in you, which you have heard from the beginning' . . . Nothing has direct divine authority for the believer, but that which was from 'the beginning'."

Sincerely,

Paul Kerr

cc:
• Dr. J.I. Packer, Professor of Theology, Regent College
• Dr. R.C. Sproul, Professor of Theology, Reformed Theology Seminary
• Dr. Charles Swindoll, President , Dallas Theological Seminary
• Dr. George E. Meisinger, Dean, Chafer Theological Seminary
• Dr. Daniel L. Akin, Dean, School of Theology, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
• Dr. Joseph M. Stowell, President, Moody Bible Institute
• Dr. Duane Litfin, President, Wheaton College
• Dr. Harold O.J. Brown, Professor of Theology, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School
• Dr. Sinclair Ferguson, Professor of Theology, Westminster Theological Seminary
• Harold Myra, President & Chief Editor, Christianity Today Magazine

Read on...

Identifying a Cult

by Jan Groenveld

There has been much confusion about cults and how to 'pickem'.

Some have difficulty identifying a cult because it is not so easy to identify one that is not even religious. For this reason, over the years, different definitions of what actually is a cult have developed to make it easier when you know little about their beliefs.

The different definitions:Secular definition

Cult - From the Latin "cultis" which denotes all that is involved in worship, ritual, emotion, liturgy and attitude. This definition actually denotes what we call denominations and sects and would make all religious movements a cult.

Christian definition

Cult - Any group which deviates from Biblical, orthodox, historical Christianity. e.i. They deny the Deity of Christ; His physical resurrection; His personal and physical return to earth and salvation by FAITH alone.

This definition only covers those groups which are cults within the Christian religion. It does not cover cults within other world religions such as Islam and Hinduism. Nor does it cover Psychological, Commercial or Educational cults which do not recognize the Bible as a source of reality.

Universal definition

Cult - Any group which has a pyramid type authoritarian leadership structure with all teaching and guidance coming from the person/persons at the top. The group will claim to be the only way to God; Nirvana; Paradise; Ultimate Reality; Full Potential, Way to Happiness etc, and will use thought reform or mind control techniques to gain control and keep their members.

This definition covers cults within all major world religions, along with those cults which have no OBVIOUS religious base such as commercial, educational and psychological cults. Others may define these a little differently, but this is the simplest to work from.

The 'orthodox Bible-based cult'

A group is called a cult because of their behaviour - not their doctrines. Doctrine is an issue in the area of Apologetics and Heresy. Most religious cults do teach what the Christian church would declare to be heresy but some do not. Some cults teach the basics of the Christian faith but have behavioural patterns that are abusive, controlling and cultic.

This occurs in both Non-Charismatic and Charismatic churches. These groups teach the central doctrines of the Christian faith and then add the extra authority of leadership or someone's particular writings. They centre around the interpretations of the leadership and submissive and unquestioning acceptance of these is essential to be a member of good standing. This acceptance includes what we consider non-essential doctrines e.i. not salvation issues (such as the Person and Work of Christ.) The key is that they will be using mind control or undue influence on their members.

An excellent book on this subject is "Churches that Abuse" by Dr Ronald Enroth.

Using these guidelines of definition, Bible-based, Psychological, Educational and Commercial aberrations can easily be identified.

Other identification marks

The group will have an ELITIST view of itself in relation to others, and a UNIQUE CAUSE. i.e. THEY ARE THE ONLY ONES RIGHT - everyone else is wrong. THEY ARE THE ONLY ONES DOING GOD'S WILL - everyone else is in apostasy.

They will promote their cause actively, and in doing so, abuse God-given personal rights and freedoms. This abuse can be THEOLOGICAL, SPIRITUAL, SOCIAL & PSYCHOLOGICAL.

How they do this

• Their leader/s may claim a special, exclusive ministry, revelation or position of authority given by God.
• They believe they are the only true church and take a critical stance regarding the Christian church while at the same time praising and exalting their own group, leader/s and work.
• They use intimidation or psychological manipulation to keep members loyal to their ranks. This could be in the form of threats of dire calamity sent by God if they leave; certain death at Armageddon; being shunned by their family and friends etc. This is a vital part of the mind control process.
• Members will be expected to give substantial financial support to the group. This could be compulsory tithing (which is checked); signing over all their property on entering the group; coercive methods of instilling guilt on those who have not contributed; selling magazines, flowers or other goods for the group as part of their "ministry".
At the same time bible-based cults may ridicule churches that take up free-will offerings by passing collection plates and/or sell literature and tapes. They usually brag that they don't do this. This gives outsiders the intimation that they are not interested in money.
• There will be great emphasis on loyalty to the group and its teachings. The lives of members will be totally absorbed into the group's activities. They will have little or no time to think for themselves because of physical and emotional exhaustion. This is also a vital part of the mind control process.
• There will be total control over almost all aspects of the private lives of members. This control can be direct through communal living, or constant and repetitious teaching on "how to be a true Christian" or "being obedient to leadership". Members will look to their leaders for guidance in everything they do.
• Bible-based cults may proclaim they have no clergy/laity distinction and no paid ministry class - that they are all equal.
• Any dissent or questioning of the group's teachings is discouraged. Criticism in any form is seen as rebellion. There will be an emphasis on authority, unquestioning obedience and submission. This is vigilantly maintained.
• Members are required to demonstrate their loyalty to the group in some way. This could be in the form of "dobbing" on fellow members (including family) under the guise of looking out for their "spiritual welfare". They may be required to deliberately lie (heavenly deception) or give up their lives by refusing some form of medical treatment.
• Attempts to leave or reveal embarrassing facts about the group may be met with threats. Some may have taken oaths of loyalty that involve their lives or have signed a "covenant" and feel threatened by this. Refugees of the group are usually faced with confrontations by other members with coercion to get them to return to the group.

Some abuses of rights and freedoms

• Abuse of individuality: They adopt a "groupness" mentality. They are not permitted to think for themselves apart from the group and only accept what they are told.
• Abuse of intimacy: Relationships with friends, relatives, spouses, children, parents etc are broken or seriously hampered.
• Abuse of finances: Pressure to give all you can to the group. In non-communal groups, members usually live at the lower socio-economic strata, not because of a lower income level, but because they are always giving money to the group for some reason.
• "Us versus them" mentality: Isolation from the community in general. Anyone and everything outside the group is seen as "of the devil" or "unenlightened" etc. Their enemies now include former friends; the Christian church; governments; education systems; the media - the world in general. Those who are involved with these in any way see such involvement as a "means to an end".
• Abuse of time and energy: The group controls and uses almost all the members time and energy in group activities. They are usually in a constant state of mental and physical exhaustion.
• Abuse of free will: They must unquestioning submit to the groups teachings and directions and their own free will is broken. Their "will" actually becomes the groups "will" without their realizing it. This is done either by coercive methods including low protein diets and lack of sleep, or over a period of time through intimidation. Both methods make heavy use of "guilt".

Results of this abuse

• Personality changes: Relatives will say they no longer recognize the person. From a warm, loving personality will come heaped abuse, rejection and feelings of hate. The cult member sees himself as "righteous" in comparison and this comes across in their attitude toward all outsiders.
• Loss of identity: They cannot see themselves as individuals apart from the group. Some even change their name as a rejection of their former life.
• Paranoia - We are being persecuted: Any time you say anything negative about the group, whether justified or no, it is regarded as "persecution". Any criticism of the individual is also seen as persecution only because they are the "true Christian" or "enlightened" one - not because they, as an individual, have done the wrong thing. However, at the same time they will feel free to criticize whatever you believe, say and do because they are "the only ones who are right".
• Social disorientation: They lose their ability to socialize outside the group. This can go so far as to not being able to structure their time or make simple decisions for themselves when they leave. Their world-view alters and they perceive the world through their leaders eyes. They become very naive about life in general.
• Severe guilt complexes: They are made to feel guilty of everything they did before entering the group and are to strive to be "good" and "worthy" for "eternal life". Misdemeanors are made into "mountains" so that members are in a constant state of guilt for infringing even the most minor rules. Guilt comes because they aren't doing enough; entertaining doubts or questions; even thinking rationally for oneself.
This guilt is piled upon pile with new rules constantly being laid down about what is sinful and what is not. Illness may be seen as lack of faith - more guilt. Emotional illness may be seen as proof of sin in your life - more guilt.

Summary

Not all these points will be found in every cult, but all cults will have some if not most of them, although these may vary to some degree.

Copyright 1985-1995 Jan Groenveld
Internet Address: py101663@student.uq.edu.au
Mail: PO Box 2444 Mansfield Q 4122 Australia

Reproduction is permitted only if text is intact. The above identifying information must be left intact.

Read on...

Wednesday, 22 August 2007

The $136-million Suit They Lost

For six years, the Living Stream Ministry (LSM) pursued a huge $136-million suit against Harvest House, the most recent in a chain of lawsuits against Christians spanning thirty years. I remind one of that fact to show that they are not nice, tolerant, harmless people. For those six years, the suit was a big deal and indeed the LSM thought it was such a big deal, that they pursued it while losing every step of the way.

Now that it is over, we are to believe that it was no big deal after all. It was just small quibbling.

Here is a quotation I found from the original letter they wrote to Harvest House prepatory to the litigation they lost:

According to Dr. Ankerberg and Dr. Weldon [editors of the Encyclopedia of Cults an New Religion], cults engage in a variety of very bad, unwholesome and morally bankrupt practices. For example, the book alleges that cults subject their members to “physical” and “psychological” “harm”, engage in the “perversion of sexuality,” “restrict” the “independent thought” of their members, and demand “unquestioning obedience” to group “leaders.” The authors further allege that cults engage in “occult practices,” engineer “cover ups of the group’s history” or that of its “leaders,” subject members to “intimidation,” perpetrate “deception and fraud,” engage in fraudulent “fund raising,” and issue deceptive statements concerning “financial costs.” The authors go so far as to suggest that these cults practice “witchcraft” and literally cause “cancer” in their members. (4th paragraph, link here.)

Let's talk about those charges.

First, the LSM cult had only a brief entry in the Encyclopedia. The entry is actually quite fair; it is almost favorable to the Liites. The encyclopedia actually never said any of these things about the LSM cult. But if they did, they would have been correct.

Let's have a look at the above paragraph, point by point.

Physical harm - I know of children who were beaten; elders encouraged it as a way of controlling children who were "rebellious," meaning they wanted to go swimming in the public pool, which was "worldly." Adults are routinely deprived of sleep, especially in the ten-day long training camps. They use that on terrorists at Guatanamo Bay. I would call that physical harm.

Psychological harm - You bet. Most people can spot that there is something seriously wrong with the LSM cult and walk out with frightened looks at their first meeting. When I was a kid, my friends said the cult was "scary." My friends were right.

The psychological harm is to be expected from a cult that takes a literal and complete view of "denying the self." Li taught that man was totally evil, not in the Calvinist way that all things have been corrupted; Li taught that each thing was totally evil. God regretted his creation and would not give it the second chance he gave after Noah's flood. Man, particularly his soul, was wholly evil. So according to Li, believers must deny it wholly. Likes, dislikes, opinions were to be suppressed.

Just how this was to be done was the subject of many of the meetings. Leaders would give examples from their daily lives. Followers were pressured to give public confessions of how they failed to deprive themselves of everything they liked, leaving no stone unturned.

Meetings were five or six times a week (if you count the two Sunday morning meetings separately), sometimes lasting as long as three hours. Followers of Li were also expected to pay for and attend two super intensive training camps a year. This is stressful.

Whatever latent psychological problem you may have had before coming to the group would erupt out of control in these conditions. I knew people who had a minor eating problem suddenly explode to triple their weight. Why? they were taught that dieting was fleshly, and that to deny the self they needed to stop it. I knew a woman who at the age of thirty had a full psychotic episode and was diagnosed schizophrenic, as were others I knew. When her family pulled her out of the cult, her hallucinations stopped. I know several others who became homosexuals after years of suppressing their natural instincts in the cult.

All this is psychological harm.

Perversion of sexuality - Besides the above reaction to unnatural suppression of human instincts, there is the famous impropriety of Li's son Philip, whom Li designated his successor and appointed president of the LSM offices. Top leaders finally saw the light of the nature of Li and left over the incident including: Max Rappoport, who had set Li up in his headquarters at Anaheim, California; John Ingalls, the editor of all things LSM; Albert Knoch, the principle ghost-writer for literature published under Li's name; and Bill Duane, the translator of Li's Recovery Version of the Bible.

Occult practices - If you consider that Li taught that you could literally become God (not like God) by pray-reading his writings occult, then yes, the cult is occult.

Restriction of independent thouight - Absolutely. Elders controlled every aspect of your life, including whom you would marry, and how you should discipline your children. Only LSM materials were permitted in cult meetings. Members were discouraged from watching TV, going to movies, celebrating Christmas or birthdays. If you were ever found to be reading religious material not published by the LSM, you would be shunned and could eventually even be excommunicated.

Cover ups of the group’s history - All the time. Internet forums are full of the Daystar financial fiasco. The LSM denies this ever happened. The internet is filled with information regarding Philip Li's sexual improprieties. The LSM denies this ever happened. Li himself was constantly changing and inflating his own life history, from a poorly educated Chinese peasant to a graduate of a Chinese Christian university. Even the late lawsuit against Harvest House is now being suppressed. It is too recent to deny they lost, but instead they minimize it -- as if $136-million was a small matter.

Intimidation - What is more intimidating than a $136-million lawsuit? They have been suing people regularly over the past thirty years. And what about what happened to Jim Moran's website?

Deception and fraud - I think there are enough references above to more than cover this point and the others remaining. The LSM is an extremely profitable business. All its sales are tax-deductible. Much or most of its income comes from cash donations -- with no paper trail whatsoever.

The LSM charged that Harvest House said all these things. They did not.

They could have.

Read on...

Mingling and Soul-Slaying

Please read my introduction to mingling here: "Who are the Liites?" (II).

There are three main problems to Li's idea of mingling, which is the idea that man's nature is literally replaced with all that God is.

(1) That the infinite God is literally placed within the confines of finite men;
(2) That men can literally become not just like God, but become God;
(3) That for this to happen, the old man — the self, the soul, the "I" — must be totally destroyed without redemption.

The last point is repeatedly drilled into active members. And it should be obvious that for you literally to become God, you cannot remain yourself.

When Scripture says to deny the self, Li takes it not only literally, but completely.

Galatians 2:20 ("No longer I, but Christ lives in me") is frequently quoted and taken literally and absolutely; your soul is literally crucified; you are absolutely dead; infinite God is literally inside finite man. Now there are six instances in the gospels where Christ tells us that he who would save his life shall lose it. The Liites rightfully note that this can also be translated "soul;" but in practice they ignore the second half of the verses that show that Christ wanted to save your soul.

To the Christian, it is not only impossible to contain God literally, but as God saves us, we become more dependant on him while becoming what he created us to be. But to the Liite, "saving the soul" means replacing it with God (literally). But if you are replaced, you are not there. There is nothing to save.

Becoming more of yourself is impossible to the Liite since the soul, along with all creation, is totally evil. It is totally evil not in the Calvinist sense, where evil and corruption is everywhere, but it is evil through and through.

Li taught that God's perfect nature is incompatible with man's fallen nature, evil through and through. Evil must be destroyed. As finite man absorbs the infinite God, God, as Li said "crosses out," "annihilates," "replaces" the human nature with himself. Man does not become like God, he becomes God. Already, that this is the soul extinction of nirvana should be clear.

I remember one testimony made by one elder that typifies the thousands of like testimonies. He went shopping for a doorbell. He spent some time picking one out at a hardware store, when suddenly he realized he was not following proper teaching. By picking out the doorbell, he was expressing his self. He was expressing his human nature. He was expressing his soul, his personality. But the self, human nature, the soul, the personality is sinful, meaning it is evil through and through.

You will note that although he said his soul was sinful, nowhere in this elder's testimony was an indication of a sin. He needed a doorbell and he was buying one. That was evil. You see, Li taught that man does not commit sins; he literally IS sin. So Christ's coming to destroy sin does not mean he just wanted to make you stop sinning, he wanted to stop you from existing.

Remember, the Christian believes that man was created in the image of God, but fell. Christ's salvific work returns man to the image of God and thereby redeems him from sin. If I say that "man becomes God," I mean a metaphor, because obviously finite man cannot become infinite God. In another metaphor, Christ said that we are his "sheep" and he is the "gate." But I do not bleat, and Christ is not made of cast iron. These are figures that beautifully explain spiritual concepts. Were Li to be consistent and interpret all metaphors literally, we would not only lose the beauty in the Bible, it would no longer make sense.

Read on...

Tuesday, 21 August 2007

PyroManiac: Publisher prevails in important lawsuit

PyroManiac: Publisher prevails in important lawsuit

Read on...

Key Dogmas and Rituals

See also Liite and Traditional Buddhist Terms.

▪ Anti-salvation - Li taught that man's soul must be utterly destroyed. Since the soul is totally evil, it cannot be saved. Instead, Li taught that the soul must be replaced by an alien spirit through a process called "mingling" and to effect what Li called "salvation," ie, anti-salvation. Salvation was the beginning of the process.

▪ Anti-redemption - Nothing of man's soul can be retained; however, its destruction does produce a harvest. The alien spirit that replaces the soul grows inside the hulking space left behind in the destruction. Eventually this spirit is reabsorbed into its greater self in what Li called "redemption;" that is, anti-redemption. Redemption was the end of the process.

▪ Soul-murder - The process of destroying a man's soul and replacing it over time with an alien spirit takes place by mixing the two natures together. The proportions of the alien spirit that Li called "God" is increased while the man's soul is decreased. Ultimately so much of the alien spirit has been added that nothing is left of the man. The man is destroyed. That man becomes the alien spirit, which Li names "God." Li called this process "mingling."

▪ Luciferianism - Li taught that the "heart of the Gospel" is: "God became man that man could become God." Li does not mean this as a metaphor, that a believer can become like God; he means that he and his followers actually become God. This is the same as the original sin that Lucifer performed before he was cast out of Heaven. That a created being should desire to become God is Luciferian.

▪ Nirvana - Although apotheosis (Luciferianism) is promoted as a selling-point for Liite doctrine, in actual fact it is a part of a broader doctrine of mingling (see Soul-murder) in which is the soul is annihilated and reabsorbed into the all that is God. This is clearly the extinction of Buddhist nirvana.

▪ Bibliolatry - Li taught that "God-inspired" meant "God's essence" and thus the very words of the Bible were God himself and worthy of worship. Since the words themselves were holy, only the version of the Bible that Li approved and profited from could be worshipped as God. Furthermore, any of Li's published messages and notes to that version of the Bible were required to be worshipped as God. Worship of the words takes place in a ritual Li called "Pray-reading." See Praying meaningless words in repetition below.

▪ God's head - Li never acquired more than a limited grasp of English. During one of his three-hour long sermons it became clear that he thought that the word "Godhead" (properly meaning Godness or divinity) meant God's head. The audience immediately erupted into laughter, thinking that this was an honest mistake of a simple Chinese man — and endearing. Li, however thought his audience was mocking him. So he created a new etymology of the word to show, as he said, that he "knew English better than you Americans." This was fitted into Li's dogmatic scheme to explain how man became God but not part of the Christians' Trinity: man became God, but not the Godhead; man became the body of Christ but not God's head.

▪ Emptying the mind - Li taught that the process of mingling can only take place if the mind is emptied. Orthodoxy knows this as a very dangerous practice during which the mind enters the spiritual realms and is thus vulnerable to spiritual attack far worse than flirting with Ouija Boards. Hesychasts teach analogous Christian practice only with extreme caution. Even saints could be subjected to attack when in meditative visionary states. Li, however, directed his followers to empty their minds through two methods. This had the added convenience that a minded thus emptied could not be critical of nonsense and craven requests for money.

  1. Mocking the name of the Lord - Li taught that salvation was a once and for all event that occurred only when a person shouted at the top of his lungs "O LORD JESUS!" ten times in public. This desensitizes the person to the Lord's name ands trivializes salvation to a meaningless technique. When a person accustomed to shouting these words in Local Church meetings hears the Lord's name invoked with sincerity, it means nothing to him. Li called this ritual "Calling upon the name of the Lord."
  2. Praying meaningless words in repetition - Li taught that in addition to screaming the Lord's name, his followers must pick random words from the Bible, forget what they mean, and repeat them at least ten times prayerfully. Grammatical words such as "the", "a", "many", etc were particularly to be stressed. Li justified this by saying that all scripture was "God-breathed" and thus literally the substance of God. The follower who did was said "to eat the God" and thus continued the process of Mingling. Li called this ritual "Pray-reading the Word" and "eating the Lord."

▪ Chaos - Li taught that his followers should lead a "spiritual life" that was spontaneous and free. Each long Local Church meeting is a psychological (not literal) orgy of screaming, emotional outbursts, gasps, public confessions of personal weakness, recitation of official slogans, punching the air, and jumping up and down. This is chaos. To be sure, none of this is spontaneous; each meeting is a rehearsal of the next and only the correct words, phrases and ways of punching and jumping are allowed. This is strictly enforced. Followers will be shouted down or shouted to sit down and shut up if they do not perform the chaos correctly. Slow learners are shunned socially and humiliated until they get it right. In addition to the chaos of the meetings, followers' personal lives are likewise often in chaos: latent neuroses and fears come to dominate their lives and their finances often skyrocket out of control.

▪ Christians face a fate worse than hell - Li taught that a Christian was someone who had begun the process of ingesting God. Once a piece of God was "imparted" into the man, God could never destroy the man as easily as he could a non-Christian. The Christian who did not accept Li's doctrine of Mingling would never become God. The alien spirit Li called "God" could not reunite from the man to himself if there were still parts of the man in the man. The solution was that all Christians would be cast into outer darkness, where there is "weeping and gnashing of teeth" until they accepted Li's doctrines. If after a thousand years of eternity they still refused, they were then sent to Hell where their souls would be destoyed as Li's God intended. Thus the fate of Christian is worse that of a non-Christian: he is rewarded with outer darkness and Hell too.

▪ Christianity, the synagogue of Satan - Li taught that those who had not heard his doctrines are neutral but that Christians are the Devil's own. He also called Christianity "Babylon the Great."

▪ Amorality - Li did not teach morality or ethics. Instead he said that preaching morality was the purview of "shallow Christianity." Members of his Local Church had not need of such talk, he said, since they were already the most moral persons on earth by nature of becoming God.

▪ Unitarianism - Li claimed he was "trinitarian" but taught otherwise. To him, the persons of the Holy Trinity simply represented stages in the process he called "Mingling." God the Son was just God being born. The Holy Spirit was just the fluid whereby the mortal man Jesus became God the Father. God the Father was end the result of the process.

▪ God's economy - see Soul-murder.

Read on...

Post-Cult Trauma Syndrome

After exiting a cult, an individual may experience a period of intense and often conflicting emotions. She or he may feel relief to be out of the group, but also may feel grief over the loss of positive elements in the cult, such as friendships, a sense of belonging or the feeling of personal worth generated by the group's stated ideals or mission. The emotional upheaval of the period is often characterized by "Post-Cult Trauma Syndrome" (PCTS):

• spontaneous crying
• sense of loss
• depression & suicidal thoughts
• fear that not obeying the cult's wishes will result in God's wrath or loss of salvation
• alienation from family, friends
• sense of isolation, loneliness due to being surrounded by people who have no basis for understanding cult life
• fear of evil spirits taking over one's life outside the cult
• scrupulosity, excessive rigidity about rules of minor importance
• panic disproportionate to one's circumstances
• fear of going insane
• confusion about right and wrong
• sexual conflicts
• unwarranted guilt

The period of exiting from a cult is usually a traumatic experience and, like any great change in a person's life, involves passing through stages of accommodation to the change:

• Disbelief/denial: "This can't be happening. It couldn't have been that bad."
• Anger/hostility: "How could they/I be so wrong?" (hate feelings)
• Self-pity/depression: "Why me? I can't do this."
• Fear/bargaining: "I don't know if I can live without my group. Maybe I can still associate with it on a limited basis, if I do what they want."
• Reassessment: "Maybe I was wrong about the group's being so wonderful."
• Accommodation/acceptance: "I can move beyond this experience and choose new directions for my life" or...
• Reinvolvement: "I think I will rejoin the group."

Passing through these stages is seldom a smooth progression. It is fairly typical to bounce back and forth between different stages. Not everyone achieves the stage of accommodation / acceptance. Some return to cult life. But for those who do not, the following may be experienced for a period of several months:

• flashbacks to cult life
• simplistic black-white thinking
• sense of unreality
• suggestibility, ie. automatic obedience responses to trigger-terms of the cult's loaded language or to innocent suggestions
• disassociation (spacing out)
• feeling "out of it"
• "Stockholm Syndrome": knee-jerk impulses to defend the cult when it is criticized, even if the cult hurt the person
• difficulty concentrating
• incapacity to make decisions
• hostility reactions, either toward anyone who criticizes the cult or toward the cult itself
• mental confusion
• low self-esteem
• dread of running into a current cult-member by mistake
• loss of a sense of how to carry out simple tasks
• dread of being cursed or condemned by the cult
• hang-overs of habitual cult behaviours like chanting
• difficulty managing time
• trouble holding down a job

Most of these symptoms subside as the victim mainstreams into everyday routines of normal life. In a small number of cases, the symptoms continue.

* This information is a composite list from the following sources: "Coming Out of Cults," by Margaret Thaler Singer, Psychology Today, Jan. 1979, P. 75; "Destructive Cults, Mind Control and Psychological Coercion", Positive Action Portland, Oregon, and "Fact Sheet," Cult Hot-Line and Clinic, New York City.

Read on...

Summary of Doctrines

In the beginning, God. In the end, God.

Li's doctrinal scheme was simply Li's folk understanding of the Buddhist notion of nirvana. Li did not believe in an eternal soul that was separable from nature. Instead, he believed that every man's soul would be destroyed without exception. Man had a choice whether to allow this destruction to lead him to hell or to lead to the empty hulk of his destroyed soul returning to God. The soul becomes nothing, the soul joins God. This is nirvana and bears no resemblance to the salvation in Christianity.

Further, God too follows the same process. God's nature is not immutable and eternal. Since man becomes God, God undergoes the process while man does. This means that in effect God is nothing more than the "All" of Buddhism. Thus since Lee's scheme requires that God is both Creator and the created, the individual and the all, Lee taught pantheism.

Moreover, Li taught that the process of soul-destruction and returning to God involved mechanical processes whereby definite proportions of God would replace the man's soul, destroy it and then return to itself, Lee was establishing materialistic mechanisms for the spiritual realm. This reduced the spiritual to the material.

In short, Li was a pantheistic materialism, which is essentially what Buddhism is. Naturally did not possess the education to elucidate this, but on the other hand he was selling his understanding of the Chinese folk Buddhism he was raised under in China as Christianity to a Christian culture; he would not have sold this successfully were he up front about it. Be that as it may, Li's methods of emptying the mind with meaningless words are traits specific to Buddhism of the Far East and Li's soul-destruction = the nothingness of nirvana.

Read on...