The Liites win two entries under "Really Bad Theology" at the Spurgeon Archive.
Affirmation & Critique - This is the journal of "The Local Church" movement, whose guru was Witness Lee. The vagueness of the pseudo-scholarly writing you'll find here is the only thing that disguises how bad this theology is. (See "Amana Christian Bookstore" below.) This group is prone to be litigious against people who label them a "cult." Cult or not, I think their theology is deplorable. So sue me.
Amana Christian Bookstore - Touting the works of Watchman Nee and Witness Lee. The followers of these two writers belong to a movement called "The Local Church," which advocates some—um—rather unusual views on church polity, mysticism, and the Scriptures. Their movement has often been called cultish, and they have used litigation to try to quell the labeling of their movement as a "cult." This Web site has a section devoted to telling their side of one such lawsuit. The documents related to the lawsuit you'll find here are fascinating. The theology promulgated here, however, is bad. For an account of why it is bad theology, see the material retrieved from Jim Moran's Light of Truth Ministries Web Site. (After Moran's unexpected death in January 2003, The Local Church purchased rights to Moran's exposés of their group and his domain names, and have tried to squelch the information that material contains). Finally, although we do not recommend Miles Stanford's material in general, (see under "Bad Theology"), he wrote an informative critique of Nee and Lee.
"Proudly serving roadkill from the information superhighway since 1995."
Phil Johnson is an ordained elder at Grace Community Church of Sun Valley, California, USA.
Source: Phil Johnson's Bookmarks
Friday, 8 August 2008
Phil Johnson's Bookmarks
Sunday, 3 February 2008
Peculiar Teachings of The Local Church
An interview with Neil Duddy in UPDATE magazine.
by Johannes Aagaard and Thomas O’Connor
In 1979, Swiss publisher Schwengeler-Verlag published a short book on a movement of six hundred churches known as The Local Church. It’s title “Die Sonderlehre des Witness Lee” translates in English as The Peculiar Teachings af Witness Lee. About 4,000 copies were sold to German-speaking Europeans.
This book was contested in Swiss court by the Stuttgart, West Germany, Local Church, but the suit and subsequent appeal were dismissed. In 1981 the Local Church took the suit to Oakland, California. Schwengeler, and the two co-authors Neil Duddy and the Spiritual Counterfeits Project (SCP) were the defendants.
We present this interview and article about the teachings of the Local Church and its leader Witness Lee as a service to our readers who are interested in the many variations of new religious movements found in the world today. Some, as in the case of the Local Church, have their roots in the Christian faith and can be misidentified as orthodox denominations unless close scrutiny is made of the teachings and organizational methods.
Read the full article...
Wednesday, 26 December 2007
Eternal Damnation of Christians?
Outer darkness and extinction in the eternal fires of hell.
One important thing to remember for all readers here, whether a believer in Christ or not, is that according to Witness Lee, y'all are going to hell.
On this point and many others Witness Lee's religion is just like any other cult. Take the Jehovah's Witnesses for example. The practical consequence of their god-talk is that everyone, including most Jehovah's Witnesses, is damned. The Watchtower Society, the JWs' vatican, teaches that only 144,000 will actually be saved. Now after more than 100 years of existence, the JWs have grown so that their number, living and dead, is what, in the millions? These millions of JWs (and everyone else for that matter) face everlasting extinction of their souls.
The ghostly triage.
So what does the Living Stream Ministry, the fabulously rich vatican of the Local Church, teach? It teaches a triage: of believers in Witness Lee, of Christians, and of everyone else. Good believers in Witness Lee who have pray-read Lee's writings become God. To be sure, they do not become God's head, but God's body. I am not sure where the infinite God keeps his body, but it is there waiting, literally, for finite men magically to turn into it.
And what happens to Christians, you ask? Christians do not accept Witness Lee's religion, therefore they will be cast at the end times into outer darkness for a thousand years.
But it's not that simple. There's more to it, but first I want to show you why Lee made up this doctrine because I find the story interesting. You see to make his living, Lee had to sell his tapes and books (actually they were all ghost-written by John Ingalls and Al Knoch, but that is another story) to somebody. He needed an audience. America was a Christian country, he was told, and so he decided to market his material toward Christians. Thus he would publish his materials using the same technical vocabulary that Christians use.
Lee heard a lot of Christians talk about "getting saved," so he would, too. However as one might expect, Lee didn't really understand what getting saved was; but that didn't matter, he would make up his own definition and sell that as a new revelation from God.
The king is dead, long live the king.
For his revelation, Lee turned to his native China, the land of leaving fruit do the goddess of money and the land where the uttermost joy was Nirvana; that is, to become nothing and merge with God who was All. Lee's twist on Nirvana was that everyone who pray-read his words literally took a piece of God within him. "Getting saved" was the first piece of God you get. The process is like tea in water: tea dissolves, mingling with the water, making the water tea-like. The more tea you add into the cup, the less water there is. If you keep adding tea, at length the cup will be full of tea and empty of water. In the end there is no water, only tea.
In other words, you cease to exist; you are God. The king is dead, long live the king.
Now to loop back to the fate of Christians.
Because Christians "get saved," they still have that first piece of God inside them. But since they failed to purchase Lee's massive amount of materials and failed to pray-read them, this first piece never grew. The tea-cup has a little tiny piece of tea in it, but it is still mostly water. Since you, the wicked Christian, did not buy and pray-read Lee's stuff, you are not God yet and you can't be admitted unto heaven.
But since you do have a tiny piece of God in you, you can't go to hell straightway because God does not like it there. So instead, you are sent to 1000 years of outer darkness, where there is weeping and gnashing of teeth. (Christian readers will recognize this as a perversion of Jesus' parable of the virgins.)
Now as I said far back at the beginning, the fate of Christians does not stop in outer darkness. That is only for a thousand years.
Lee taught that Christians would be granted one more chance to choose Lee's doctrines. And if they refuse? They go to hell, where the fires burn man's soul to separate out the God mingled with the man, like cinder running from a fire. When that is done, Christians will meet the same fate as Jehovah's Witnesses: their souls become extinct.
Everyone else, including Liites that did not pray-read enough Living Stream books, likewise go to hell where they are destroyed.
That leaves one unanswered question.
If a Christian at the end of his thousand years in outer darkness does choose Lee, how does his check for pray-reading material reach the Living Stream offices in Anaheim?
Friday, 7 September 2007
Violence on God
The consequences of believing you are right and everyone else is wrong.
The Liite cult imposes severe mental pain and psychological problems on followers of Li who sincerely believe in the delusions of the religion. Which religion is not Christian. This is no small point; not only does the cult attack Christianity vociferously, but its dogmas and god-talk (too simplistic to be a theology) are exactly the opposite to what Christians have always believed. For example, Liites, insisting that all the world is wrong, takes on the Holy Trinity and gets it exactly backwards. Naturally whenever Chang-Shou Li, the founder of the Liites, was told that his god-talk was wrong, he declared that he alone was right and everyone else was wrong.
This may well have been a flippant response, but it does have strategic value. Of course, Li's mistake on the Trinity was fruit of his incompetence, his inability (or stubborn refusal) to understand Christian teachings, clearly laid out long ago. But by declaring everyone wrong and him alone right, Li was exacting discipline of his followers.
That is, he was increasing their dependence on his misconstrued dogmas; since he alone was right and everyone else was wrong, his followers were obliged to buy his books, and only his books. Thus Li's was income was guaranteed as long as the hierarchy beneath Li's Living Stream Ministry was in place, and he would remain a fabulously wealthy man.
Even if one does not believe in Christ, he should be wary of anyone outright lying about his religion. Had Li admitted the truth, that he followed his own version of Buddhism and rejected Christ, he would have been socially tolerated. But Li would have had little success preaching a strange brand of Buddhism in a Christian country that had few Buddhists. He would not have been given a multi-million dollar estate in Anaheim, California. He would not have flown around the world free of charge.
Skim through the following, the ancient summation of the Persons and Substance of the Trinity, dating far back to ca. 361 AD. It is known commonly as the "Creed of Athanasius."
WHOSOEVER will be saved, before all things it is necessary that he hold the true faith.
Which faith except everyone do keep whole and undefiled, without doubt he shall perish everlastingly.
And the true faith is this: That we worship one God in trinity, and trinity in unity, neither confounding the persons, nor dividing the substance.
For there is one person of the Father, another of the Son, and another of the Holy Ghost.
But the godhead of the Father, of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost, is all one, the glory equal, the majesty co-eternal.
Such as the Father is, such is the Son, and such is the Holy Ghost.
The Father uncreate, the Son uncreate, and the Holy Ghost uncreate.
The Father incomprehensible, the Son incomprehensible, and the Holy Ghost incomprehensible.
The Father eternal, the Son eternal, and the Holy Ghost eternal.
And yet they are not three eternals, but one eternal.
As also there are not three incomprehensibles, nor three uncreated, but one uncreated, and one incomprehensible.
So likewise the Father is almighty, the Son almighty, and the Holy Ghost almighty.
And yet they are not three almighties, but one Almighty.
SO the Father is God, the Son is God, and the Holy Ghost is God.
And yet they are not three gods, but one God.
So likewise the Father is Lord, the Son Lord, and the Holy Ghost Lord.
And yet not three lords, but one Lord.
For like as we are compelled by the Christian verity to acknowledge every Person by himself to be both God and Lord,
So are we forbidden by the true religion, to say there be three gods, or three lords.
The Father is made of none, neither created, nor begotten.
The Son is of the Father alone, not made, nor created, but begotten.
The Holy Ghost is of the Father and of the Son, neither made, nor created, nor begotten, but proceeding.
SO there is one Father, not three fathers; one Son, not three sons; one Holy Ghost, not three holy ghosts.
And in this Trinity none is afore, or after other; none is greater, or less than another;
But the whole three persons are co-eternal together and co-equal.
So that in all things, as is aforesaid, the unity in trinity and the trinity in unity is to be worshipped.
He therefore that will be saved must think thus of the Trinity.
FURTHERMORE, it is necessary to everlasting salvation that he also believe rightly the Incarnation of our Lord Jesus Christ.
For the right faith is that we believe and confess that our Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God, is God and man;
GOD, of the substance of the Father, begotten before the worlds; and man of the substance of his mother, born in the world;
Perfect God and perfect man, of a reasonable soul and human flesh subsisting.
Equal to the Father, as touching his godhead; and inferior to the Father, as touching his manhood;
Who, although he be God and man, yet he is not two, but one Christ;
One, not by conversion of the Godhead into flesh but by taking of the manhood into God;
One altogether; not by confusion of substance, but by unity of person.
For as the reasonable soul and flesh is one man, so God and man is one Christ;
Who suffered for our salvation, descended into hell, rose again the third day from the dead.
He ascended into heaven, he sitteth at the right hand of the Father, God almighty, whence he will come to judge the quick and the dead.
At whose coming all men will rise again with their bodies and shall give account for their own works.
And they that have done good shall go into life everlasting; and they that have done evil into everlasting fire.
This is the catholic Faith, which except a man believe faithfully, he cannot be saved.
Now compare this with what Chang-Shou Li, the founder of the Living Stream Ministry, the Liite cult, and the "Acting God" on earth:
"The Father, the Son, and the Spirit are not three separate persons or three Gods; they are one God, one reality, one person" (Witness Lee, The Triune God to Be Life to the Tripartite Man, Anaheim: Living Stream Ministry, 1970, p. 48).
What Li has done here is reverse the Trinity; instead of God of one substance in three persons, he has three substances in one person. This is exactly the opposite to Christianity. Athanasius says "neither dividing the substance," but Li has done exactly that.
Li has performed violence on God.
Lest there be any doubt that Liites worship something besides the Christian God, read the following:
"Therefore, it is clear: The Lord Jesus is the Father, the Son, and the Spirit, and He is the very God. He is also the Lord. He is the Father, the Son, the Spirit, the Mighty God, and the Lord" (Witness Lee, The Clear Scriptural Revelation Concerning the Triune God www.contendingforthefaith.org
Once again, Li preaches a unitarian deity, but slyly calls it a "trinity."
And since Li's god changes in what he calls a "divine economy" from Jesus through the Holy Spirit to God the Father, Li's god is not the eternal, unchanging God of Christianity, but something that follows the dharma wheel of Buddhism.
Are the two views, Liite and Christian, compatible?
Athanasius says no: "except a man believe faithfully, he cannot be saved." And even more explicitly: "they that have done good shall go into life everlasting; and they that have done evil into everlasting fire." Therefore, according to Athanasius, all Liites are destined to where?
Thursday, 23 August 2007
"...That We Might Be Made God?!"
by Paul Kerr
March 1, 1998
Mr. Kerry S. Robichaux
Living Stream Ministry
1853 West Ball Road
Anaheim, CA 92804
RE: Article titled: "...That We Might Be Made God" appearing in Affirmation & Critique Vol. 1, Number 3, published by Living Stream Ministry, Anaheim, California
Dear Kerry,
While perusing the Internet I unfortunately stumbled upon your above mentioned article. That you chose for your title a partial sentence from Athanasius' De Incartione, speaks volumes. I only wonder why you waited for the last third of your piece, to finally admit that indeed the Bible does not teach that "man becomes God"?
The methodology you employ in structuring your "doctrinal" thesis is not entirely new but does offer a rather unusual variation. Most who use this method present their pet doctrine and then frantically scramble to find a few passages of Scripture to support it. You have brought this ad hoc approach to new heights! Not being deterred by lack of Biblical basis for your "man becomes God" notion, you simply resort to the extrascriptual non-canonical writings of the church "fathers", combing through them in a desperate attempt to find legitimization, all the while suggesting that Protestant theologians are somehow amiss for not doing so, and furthermore infer that these "church writings" are on the same level as Scripture.
Perhaps you are unaware that this approach to defining doctrine is justifiably discounted by most reputable non-Roman Catholic and non-Eastern Orthodox theologians of the evangelical Protestant sort, who recognize canonical Scripture as the standard authoritative measuring rod and only legitimate starting point of reference. Allow me to quote renowned theologian J.I. Packer who, I happily might add, is indeed Protestant, "Historic Protestantism...finds truth in the teaching of the canonical Scriptures as such. It receives these Scriptures as inspired, inerrant, sufficient (i.e., telling us ALL that God wills to tell us and all we need to know for salvation and eternal life), and clear (i.e. STRAIGHTFORWARD AND SELF-INTERPRETING ON ALL MATTERS OF IMPORTANCE). The first two positions (Catholicism and modernists) treat human judgements on the Bible as decisive for truth and wisdom; the third (referring to Protestantism) . . . systematically submits all human thoughts to Scripture which it takes seriously as canon." The method you use of presenting your pet doctrine of man becoming God, and providing fallible tradition as your authoritative basis, for obvious reasons is viewed with overt suspicion, especially on matters so non-essential yet controversial as man becoming God.
Furthermore, as implied by Packer, the Bible is instructive in what it does include AND what it does not include. Your admittance that the Bible does not teach that man becomes God leaves one to wonder why you do? Your rabid insistence on introducing this extrascriptual man becoming God "doctrine" into Christian circles and actually insinuating it is a crucial item of the faith is rather perplexing, as it serves no definable purpose and some would reasonably argue is grossly heretical. (An argument which you cleverly attempt to preempt by anticipating it the context of your article).
Since the notion of man becoming God is a proverbial Pandora's box, instead of criticizing Protestant theologians and so called "modern believers", you might do well to follow their wise example in keeping it closed. It is a minefield waiting to explode in the face of its proponents. I offer only two of the mines in a vast field of many:
1] You claim that your definition of man becoming God is not God as an object of worship or in certain aspects such as omnipresence, etc. Since man becoming God is not taught in the Bible who then is qualified to determine which aspects of God man becomes, and which aspects he is excluded from? You? The church "fathers"? Witness Lee? Your man becoming God "doctrine" implies the commodization of God and subsequent dissection of God into various parts. Some parts man becomes and some remain God alone. The God who indwells the believers is indeed omnipresent, or He could not indwell more than one believer at once. As this is the case, what happens to this part of God once I become Him?
2] In application, this man-becomes-God "doctrine" is especially insidious, as it provides the foundation for all manner of deviant teachings and practices to proliferate. This is especially evident in the so called "local churches" a.ka. "Lord's recovery", where this doctrine has been allowed to fester and evolve unchecked for the past few decades, quite naturally resulting in the following perfidious teachings being taught from the pulpit:
• "There is no need to pray about what to do; just follow the ministry."
• "We don't need to think, we just do what we are told."
• "Follow Witness Lee blindly. Even if he's wrong he's right."
• "Our burden is to pick up Brother Lee's teaching and way to make us all Witness Lees, like a Witness Lee duplication center."
and more recently in a letter by the full-timers at the conclusion of their training in Anaheim,
• "...we would also like to follow the trainers as the extensions of Brother Lee."
Of course, this perversion of the gospel is not too surprising as it merely represents the logical outcome and manifestation of the man-becoming-God doctrine - for if man becomes God, Witness Lee and his "extension" becomes God! It is a tiny baby step from here, over your imaginary line into the realm of blatant idolatrous man worship.
Furthermore, this man-becoming-God notion reeks of eastern mysticism. [As an aside, I find it interesting that two of your favorite "man becomes God" theorists, Athanasius and Clement, both hailed from Alexandria - a steamy hotbed of Oriental and Greek philosophies, along with every other strange teaching to appear over the horizon in ancient times.] In an era when New Age teachings are infiltrating every level of our Judeo-Christian society; when secular humanists are attacking the Church on a daily basis; with Buddhism and Hinduism gaining influence and large followings in the West; you have the brazen temerity to shamelessly disseminate this "man becomes God" concept dressed up in a Christian cloak of apparent respectability! That the apostles, by the Lord's wisdom and inspiration, did not teach that man becomes God, is not at all surprising, considering the dangerous perils and consequences associated with this matter. Since for good reason the authors of Scripture were notably cautious, one wonders why you acknowledge yet ignore this prudence and find it necessary to gleefully and with apparent abandonment join the recklessness of the church fathers by dogmatically promoting this non-canonical, extrascriptual, tradition based teaching. Considering it is a main tenet of Leeism, I suppose it is understandable that his zealous coworkers, a.k.a. his "extension", would attempt to mainstream the issue at any cost, even if it means using tradition and not Scripture as their authoritative basis.
Athanasius' usefulness during the first Council of Nice is well known - after all, they were not gathered to discuss man becoming God. However, regarding the writings of the church "fathers", I think Andrew Miller articulated it best in his Short Papers on Church History, "They may interest and instruct us but they cannot command our faith. This can only stand on the solid ground of the word of God, never on the infirm ground of tradition. 'Scripture stands alone,' as one has said, 'in majestic isolation, preeminent in instruction, and separated by unapproachable excellence from everything written by the church fathers ' . . . The definite and absolute statements of scriptures coming direct from God to the soul, are widely different from the writing of Ignatius and of all the church fathers. Our only sure and safe guide is the word of God. How seasonable then is the word in the First Epistle of John, 'Let that therefore abide in you, which you have heard from the beginning' . . . Nothing has direct divine authority for the believer, but that which was from 'the beginning'."
Sincerely,
Paul Kerr
cc:
• Dr. J.I. Packer, Professor of Theology, Regent College
• Dr. R.C. Sproul, Professor of Theology, Reformed Theology Seminary
• Dr. Charles Swindoll, President , Dallas Theological Seminary
• Dr. George E. Meisinger, Dean, Chafer Theological Seminary
• Dr. Daniel L. Akin, Dean, School of Theology, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
• Dr. Joseph M. Stowell, President, Moody Bible Institute
• Dr. Duane Litfin, President, Wheaton College
• Dr. Harold O.J. Brown, Professor of Theology, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School
• Dr. Sinclair Ferguson, Professor of Theology, Westminster Theological Seminary
• Harold Myra, President & Chief Editor, Christianity Today Magazine
Wednesday, 22 August 2007
Mingling and Soul-Slaying
Please read my introduction to mingling here: "Who are the Liites?" (II).
There are three main problems to Li's idea of mingling, which is the idea that man's nature is literally replaced with all that God is.
(1) That the infinite God is literally placed within the confines of finite men;
(2) That men can literally become not just like God, but become God;
(3) That for this to happen, the old man — the self, the soul, the "I" — must be totally destroyed without redemption.
The last point is repeatedly drilled into active members. And it should be obvious that for you literally to become God, you cannot remain yourself.
When Scripture says to deny the self, Li takes it not only literally, but completely.
Galatians 2:20 ("No longer I, but Christ lives in me") is frequently quoted and taken literally and absolutely; your soul is literally crucified; you are absolutely dead; infinite God is literally inside finite man. Now there are six instances in the gospels where Christ tells us that he who would save his life shall lose it. The Liites rightfully note that this can also be translated "soul;" but in practice they ignore the second half of the verses that show that Christ wanted to save your soul.
To the Christian, it is not only impossible to contain God literally, but as God saves us, we become more dependant on him while becoming what he created us to be. But to the Liite, "saving the soul" means replacing it with God (literally). But if you are replaced, you are not there. There is nothing to save.
Becoming more of yourself is impossible to the Liite since the soul, along with all creation, is totally evil. It is totally evil not in the Calvinist sense, where evil and corruption is everywhere, but it is evil through and through.
Li taught that God's perfect nature is incompatible with man's fallen nature, evil through and through. Evil must be destroyed. As finite man absorbs the infinite God, God, as Li said "crosses out," "annihilates," "replaces" the human nature with himself. Man does not become like God, he becomes God. Already, that this is the soul extinction of nirvana should be clear.
I remember one testimony made by one elder that typifies the thousands of like testimonies. He went shopping for a doorbell. He spent some time picking one out at a hardware store, when suddenly he realized he was not following proper teaching. By picking out the doorbell, he was expressing his self. He was expressing his human nature. He was expressing his soul, his personality. But the self, human nature, the soul, the personality is sinful, meaning it is evil through and through.
You will note that although he said his soul was sinful, nowhere in this elder's testimony was an indication of a sin. He needed a doorbell and he was buying one. That was evil. You see, Li taught that man does not commit sins; he literally IS sin. So Christ's coming to destroy sin does not mean he just wanted to make you stop sinning, he wanted to stop you from existing.
Remember, the Christian believes that man was created in the image of God, but fell. Christ's salvific work returns man to the image of God and thereby redeems him from sin. If I say that "man becomes God," I mean a metaphor, because obviously finite man cannot become infinite God. In another metaphor, Christ said that we are his "sheep" and he is the "gate." But I do not bleat, and Christ is not made of cast iron. These are figures that beautifully explain spiritual concepts. Were Li to be consistent and interpret all metaphors literally, we would not only lose the beauty in the Bible, it would no longer make sense.
Tuesday, 21 August 2007
Key Dogmas and Rituals
See also Liite and Traditional Buddhist Terms.
▪ Anti-salvation - Li taught that man's soul must be utterly destroyed. Since the soul is totally evil, it cannot be saved. Instead, Li taught that the soul must be replaced by an alien spirit through a process called "mingling" and to effect what Li called "salvation," ie, anti-salvation. Salvation was the beginning of the process.
▪ Anti-redemption - Nothing of man's soul can be retained; however, its destruction does produce a harvest. The alien spirit that replaces the soul grows inside the hulking space left behind in the destruction. Eventually this spirit is reabsorbed into its greater self in what Li called "redemption;" that is, anti-redemption. Redemption was the end of the process.
▪ Soul-murder - The process of destroying a man's soul and replacing it over time with an alien spirit takes place by mixing the two natures together. The proportions of the alien spirit that Li called "God" is increased while the man's soul is decreased. Ultimately so much of the alien spirit has been added that nothing is left of the man. The man is destroyed. That man becomes the alien spirit, which Li names "God." Li called this process "mingling."
▪ Luciferianism - Li taught that the "heart of the Gospel" is: "God became man that man could become God." Li does not mean this as a metaphor, that a believer can become like God; he means that he and his followers actually become God. This is the same as the original sin that Lucifer performed before he was cast out of Heaven. That a created being should desire to become God is Luciferian.
▪ Nirvana - Although apotheosis (Luciferianism) is promoted as a selling-point for Liite doctrine, in actual fact it is a part of a broader doctrine of mingling (see Soul-murder) in which is the soul is annihilated and reabsorbed into the all that is God. This is clearly the extinction of Buddhist nirvana.
▪ Bibliolatry - Li taught that "God-inspired" meant "God's essence" and thus the very words of the Bible were God himself and worthy of worship. Since the words themselves were holy, only the version of the Bible that Li approved and profited from could be worshipped as God. Furthermore, any of Li's published messages and notes to that version of the Bible were required to be worshipped as God. Worship of the words takes place in a ritual Li called "Pray-reading." See Praying meaningless words in repetition below.
▪ God's head - Li never acquired more than a limited grasp of English. During one of his three-hour long sermons it became clear that he thought that the word "Godhead" (properly meaning Godness or divinity) meant God's head. The audience immediately erupted into laughter, thinking that this was an honest mistake of a simple Chinese man — and endearing. Li, however thought his audience was mocking him. So he created a new etymology of the word to show, as he said, that he "knew English better than you Americans." This was fitted into Li's dogmatic scheme to explain how man became God but not part of the Christians' Trinity: man became God, but not the Godhead; man became the body of Christ but not God's head.
▪ Emptying the mind - Li taught that the process of mingling can only take place if the mind is emptied. Orthodoxy knows this as a very dangerous practice during which the mind enters the spiritual realms and is thus vulnerable to spiritual attack far worse than flirting with Ouija Boards. Hesychasts teach analogous Christian practice only with extreme caution. Even saints could be subjected to attack when in meditative visionary states. Li, however, directed his followers to empty their minds through two methods. This had the added convenience that a minded thus emptied could not be critical of nonsense and craven requests for money.
▪ Chaos - Li taught that his followers should lead a "spiritual life" that was spontaneous and free. Each long Local Church meeting is a psychological (not literal) orgy of screaming, emotional outbursts, gasps, public confessions of personal weakness, recitation of official slogans, punching the air, and jumping up and down. This is chaos. To be sure, none of this is spontaneous; each meeting is a rehearsal of the next and only the correct words, phrases and ways of punching and jumping are allowed. This is strictly enforced. Followers will be shouted down or shouted to sit down and shut up if they do not perform the chaos correctly. Slow learners are shunned socially and humiliated until they get it right. In addition to the chaos of the meetings, followers' personal lives are likewise often in chaos: latent neuroses and fears come to dominate their lives and their finances often skyrocket out of control.
▪ Christians face a fate worse than hell - Li taught that a Christian was someone who had begun the process of ingesting God. Once a piece of God was "imparted" into the man, God could never destroy the man as easily as he could a non-Christian. The Christian who did not accept Li's doctrine of Mingling would never become God. The alien spirit Li called "God" could not reunite from the man to himself if there were still parts of the man in the man. The solution was that all Christians would be cast into outer darkness, where there is "weeping and gnashing of teeth" until they accepted Li's doctrines. If after a thousand years of eternity they still refused, they were then sent to Hell where their souls would be destoyed as Li's God intended. Thus the fate of Christian is worse that of a non-Christian: he is rewarded with outer darkness and Hell too.
▪ Christianity, the synagogue of Satan - Li taught that those who had not heard his doctrines are neutral but that Christians are the Devil's own. He also called Christianity "Babylon the Great."
▪ Amorality - Li did not teach morality or ethics. Instead he said that preaching morality was the purview of "shallow Christianity." Members of his Local Church had not need of such talk, he said, since they were already the most moral persons on earth by nature of becoming God.
▪ Unitarianism - Li claimed he was "trinitarian" but taught otherwise. To him, the persons of the Holy Trinity simply represented stages in the process he called "Mingling." God the Son was just God being born. The Holy Spirit was just the fluid whereby the mortal man Jesus became God the Father. God the Father was end the result of the process.
▪ God's economy - see Soul-murder.
Summary of Doctrines
In the beginning, God. In the end, God.
Li's doctrinal scheme was simply Li's folk understanding of the Buddhist notion of nirvana. Li did not believe in an eternal soul that was separable from nature. Instead, he believed that every man's soul would be destroyed without exception. Man had a choice whether to allow this destruction to lead him to hell or to lead to the empty hulk of his destroyed soul returning to God. The soul becomes nothing, the soul joins God. This is nirvana and bears no resemblance to the salvation in Christianity.
Further, God too follows the same process. God's nature is not immutable and eternal. Since man becomes God, God undergoes the process while man does. This means that in effect God is nothing more than the "All" of Buddhism. Thus since Lee's scheme requires that God is both Creator and the created, the individual and the all, Lee taught pantheism.
Moreover, Li taught that the process of soul-destruction and returning to God involved mechanical processes whereby definite proportions of God would replace the man's soul, destroy it and then return to itself, Lee was establishing materialistic mechanisms for the spiritual realm. This reduced the spiritual to the material.
In short, Li was a pantheistic materialism, which is essentially what Buddhism is. Naturally did not possess the education to elucidate this, but on the other hand he was selling his understanding of the Chinese folk Buddhism he was raised under in China as Christianity to a Christian culture; he would not have sold this successfully were he up front about it. Be that as it may, Li's methods of emptying the mind with meaningless words are traits specific to Buddhism of the Far East and Li's soul-destruction = the nothingness of nirvana.
History
The man calling himself "Li Chang-Shou" (this is like calling himself "John Smith" or John Doe: Li and Chang are the most common names among the Chinese, a nation of four billions) hailed from the People's Republic of China (PRC); ca. 1955, he fled to Taiwan (RoC). There he joined the Little Flock, a relatively new organization of Chinese Christians founded by Watchman Nee. Since the PRC held Nee in prison incognito, the Taiwanese could not verify Li's association with Nee. Within two years Li attempted to take over Nee's Little Flock congregation in Taipei, Taiwan (RoC). Nee himself held a number of controversial beliefs, most notably his advocacy for strong authority of leaders over followers. Such centralized authority can often be a temptation for the wrong kind of personalities. However, Li's attempted take-over of Nee's Little Flock in Taipei ultimately failed, but not after having split hundreds of its members off into Li's own group. When leaders of the Little Flock exposed Li as a fraud with no verified connections to Watchman Nee, Li fled the RoC.
Excommunicated from Nee's group, Li flew to the United States, and representing himself as a simple Chinese Christian fleeng Communist persecution, he was able to find audiences among less sophisticated non-denominational evangelical Bible studies. Even so, Li spoke only a halting pidgin and his non-Christian sentiments quickly became apparent. Soon, a growing number of American hosts began rejecting his requests for speaking engagements and charity. By 1961, Li was left with only a single charismatic fellowship in Los Angeles who were willing to allow Li to continue speaking among them. Li continued to live off the charity of its members.
By 1962, Li attempted a take over his host in Los Angeles, just as he had done in Taiwan. This too failed. But just as in Taiwan, Li split away a large number of followers, and these American proselytes had access to a great deal more capital and organizational know-how than Li's followers in Taiwan. With this technical capital, Li was able to apply what he had learned from his experiences in Taiwan and the USA. For example, Li had for years listened to naive accusations against him of "splitting" and "creating a division of within the body of Christ;" his solution in the United States was simply to beat his hosts to the punch and accuse them of division. He argued that only his doctrines were truly Christian (actually they were Chinese folk-Buddhist), and therefore his hosts were creating division by continuing in their ways.
One of the main problems with history of the Liite religion is that there is little effort to back it up with verifiable sources. A few writers have accepted Li's claims uncritically in their own writings, and Li's religious group in turn mentions the author as evidence for Li's claims. But this cannot be taken seriously. Indeed the one Little Flock assembly in the USA, in San Francisco, never associated with Li and Li set up his own "Church in San Francsico" in opposition.
With a membership base split off from fellowships Li had visited, and under the advice of his new American hosts, Li was able to establish himself at the head of his own organized religion. In 1963, his first line of business was to have his hosts to establish a publishing business dedicated to printing only his writings. "Writings" here does not mean literally anything that Li wrote; Li's English was oral and simple. However his American hosts found no want of followers they could instruct to transcribe his oral messages for higher-ranking members to edit for print. This was the beginning of the Living Stream Ministry, which would quickly become the de facto Vatican of Li's new and increasingly lucrative "Local Church" hierarchy.
Like many other new religions and cults of the counter-cultural 1960's and 1970's, by 1974, Li's found himself the undisputed head of an organization of more than 7,000 members worldwide. A house on several acres on prime urban real estate on Ball Road in Anaheim California was built and donated to Li, valued at 4 million dollars at the time, where he lived with his fourth wife. His favorite son, Philip, lived in a similarly spacious complex on the same compound with elaborately landscaped exotic gardens, waterfalls and a heated swimming pool walled off from prying eyes of the community -- and the religion's membership. Li travelled throughout the world free of charge several times a year to lead conferences and trainings and to acquire donors, chauffeured wherever he spoke and toured.
Li stirred up controversy wherever he went and he never shirked from leveling the most basest of charges at whoever who crossed him. Long-time friends and co-workers who did the actual work of creating and building the organization were excommunicated whenever they became too popular and sensational attacks were launched against their reputations. Any writer on the outside who objectively publicized his eccentric, Buddho-Christian dogmas quickly became the subject of unrelenting persecution launched with the full force of the LSM's war-chest numbering in the hundreds of millions of dollars. Two famous victims Li persecuted were Reverend Jack Sparks and Dr. Walter Martin.
Li's own project to create a version of the Bible reflecting his views ended in a debacle. By 1991, the translator and editors of his Bible, William H. Duane, Jr, Albert Knoch, and John Ingalls were driven out and excommunicated when they hesitated to reword the version contrary to the original language and when they discovered that Li and his eldest son engaged in a sex-ring involving adultery with Chinese members of Li's Church in Southern California (particularly at the Liite cell in Rosemead) and elsewhere. The ensuing controversy almost ended the organization since it belied any pretense of morality even by "the world's" standards.
In this Local Church drama, however, the leadership who discovered the improprieties failed to act quickly and eventually left Li's organization in confusion. They did not pursue any aggressive stance against Li and his church. Perhaps they felt guilty about setting Li's religion in the first place. This left Li in control of an immense tax-free war-chest in the LSM. Bust just as the Jehovah's Witnesses lost a huge chunk of their membership when the Lord did return in the sky in 1974, Local Church activities resumed their former speed. When Li died in 1997, he was recognized by his church as the "Acting God" (attained through a "process" Li called "mingling"). A scramble among Li's Chinese followers established a new leader of the LSM and its subsidiary Local Church franchises, when Andrew Yu surfaced as the new head of the LSM and thus of the entire Liite religion.
Over the course of its history, the LSM has persecuted -- indeed sued -- nearly a dozen Christian publishers. The latest persecution was a $136-million dollar lawsuit against Harvest House for brief mention in an encyclopedia of American religious cults. The LSM pursued the case for six years against Harvest Publishers, losing every step of the way. Although the case was undoubtedly costly, the LSM accumulates a large war-chest during each suit through massive donation drives from members. So in the end, a lawsuit not only scares away potential research into the LSM, it also is enormously lucrative.
But now that the Liites have failed to silence the latest voice of a martyr, it may well be safe to print the truth for the world, with God's grace.
Introduction
The LSM Cult: The Liites
The Liites are a pseudo-Christian, Buddhist religion headquartered in Anaheim, California, USA under the title, "Living Stream Ministry" (LSM). In order to protect the secrecy of the organization, the LSM does not take a name for its subsidiary cell-franchises and aggressively sues anyone who attempts to shine attention on its activities. Franchises of the Local Church can be located in phone books under the nondescript heading "The Church in" followed by the name of the city where the cell is incorporated for business. The organization is also known among members as "The Lord's Recovery" or simply "The Church."
Although its dogmas can be described approximately as Chinese folk-Buddhist, the Local Church of Witness Lee couches these dogmas in Christian terminology while maintaining sharp antagonism against Christianity itself. It markets its own version of the Bible which it calls the "Recovery Version," a name that explains its pseudo- and anti-Christian beliefs as "recovering" the Buddhist doctrinal roots its founder believed underlie Christianity. Its founder, Chang-Shou Li, known to his followers as "Witness Lee," denied that the organization he founded had Buddhist roots. In the United States, the Local Church continues to hold a majority of Americans in membership, with a substantial number of Mandarin-speaking Chinese transplants who dominate the leadership.
Tuesday, 14 August 2007
Who are the Liites? (VI) - Hate
Perhaps the most notorious feature of Li's teaching was his racism and anti-semitism. A recurring theme in many of Li's sermons was Nordic blondism. He ranked Scandinavians almost at the top of the evolutionary scale, just below his own Mandarin Chinese ethnicity. At the bottom were the Japanese and Jews.
Li frequently mocked Jews and sometimes even had them stand up during conferences and trainings so he could point out their large, hooked noses, and kinky hair. Everyone would laugh at them. He would pretend it was all in fun, but the Jews were humiliated. He even took special pleasure in publicly humiliating the one Jew Li allowed in his leadership, Max Rappaport. This was most strange, since Max was responsible for establishing Li in the 1960s, particularly in using his connections to set Li up in his worldwide headquarters in Anaheim California.
Posted by
Good Christian Boy
at
20:44
Labels: Doctrine, Hate, Who are the Liites?
Who are the Liites? (V) - Persecuting the Church
Saul, Saul, wherefore persecutest thou me?.
Another notorious feature of the Liites is the persecution of Christians. Liites believe that they alone are the one true faith in the world. Christian churches are called the Whore of Babylon and Satanic. The LSM has built up a princely war chest from which it takes out lawsuits every few years against Christian publishers who dare discuss Liites openly. This is not simple revenge; each lawsuit brings in millions of dollars in donations from membership. The LSM thrives on crisis and drama; a big lawsuit is a big crisis and drama.
One such lawsuit was for more than $136 million dollars against Harvest House Christian publishers. The LSM lost, but over the six long years of the suit, you can be sure that its war-chest grew larger than ever before.
Posted by
Good Christian Boy
at
20:42
Labels: Doctrine, Who are the Liites?
Who are the Liites? (IV) - Harm
Li's conception that human nature — at least that of everyone other than himself — is absolutely evil and must be terminated has numerous consequences on the psyches of Liites. The active Liite is expected to attend five meetings a week and attend two ten-day long intensive indoctrination camps a year. Older members may attend less, but they are expected to support the LSM with donations and buying books. Since the central dogma of the Liites is Mingling, the single most important theme running though all the meetings and printed material is the worthlessness of other individuals. Man is utterly evil. Liites cannot love their neighbor because all of them are completely evil. In practice, this means that the opinions and needs of individual Liites are not only ignored, but squelched.
As may be gathered, the stress of so much activity, expectations to know LSM material, and the attack on human nature leads to distress and even nervous breakdowns.
It is for this reason that the Liites are a dangerous cult.
Posted by
Good Christian Boy
at
20:34
Labels: Doctrine, Pain, Who are the Liites?
Who are the Liites? (III) - 'New Ones'
The New Liite
Essentially there is only one way to be mingled, be terminated, and become God: through the Liite ritual of pray-reading of mantras and koans ("messages") published exclusively by the Living Stream Ministry. Pray-reading is a peculiar ritual of worshipping printed words which are full of the essence of God ("God-breathed" as they call it) and thereby absorbing the essence of God.
For example, at the first stage of Mingling, the Liite proselyte is "saved" or initiated into the process of being blotted out and becoming God. Li's "salvation" is the planting of the first seed of his god, the first tea-leaf and it occurs in the ritual known as "calling on the name of the Lord." In practice, that means the proselyte must shout as loud as he can "O Lord Jesus" ten times in front of other Liites. He is told that it is important not to think of the meaning of the words, but to "proclaim it from the depths of his human spirit." The audience then screams several mantras and the new Liite will late be 'baptized' in water.
Posted by
Good Christian Boy
at
20:28
Labels: Doctrine, Who are the Liites?
Who are the Liites? (II) - Mingling
Li is Gone. Li is God.
The fundamental Liite doctrine is Mingling.
Mingling is a re-working of the traditional Buddhist Dharma wheel. According to Li, all the world is evil and must be destroyed. This includes all humanity, which will reach its end through extinction or annihilation of the soul. Liites, too, will be annihilated — but during their lifetimes rather than at death. This is a process.
The term Mingling derives from Li's conception of three parts of man (body, soul, and spirit) as a metaphor to explain his process of annihilating the soul and replacing it with God. At initiation into the Liites, God invades the human spirit, the "innermost part of his being," then spreads to the soul.
Li said that Mingling was like steeping tea leaves in water, the tea standing for God and the water for the human soul. As the tea steeps, the water grows ever blacker. As more tea leaves are added the water becomes blacker still and as yet more leaves are added, the water is gone and only tea leaves remain.
The man is destroyed and what remains is God. In the beginning before man was made, there was God. In the end, there is only God once again. God is the alpha and omega, the beginning and the end.
Thus Liites may call themselves gods and anyone who has reached an advanced state of Mingling, such as the founder Li, is God.
Posted by
Good Christian Boy
at
20:26
Labels: Doctrine, Who are the Liites?
Who are the Liites? (I)
The Liites are a dangerous cult that take the basic doctrines of Chinese folk Buddhism and cloak them in Christian terminology. It was founded in Los Angeles, California in 1963 by Chang-Shou Li, a Chinese national who is known to Liites as Witness Lee. Shunning public exposure, Liites strenuously avoid identifying themselves in any way to outsiders. Among themselves they call the organization the "Lord's Recovery" or simply the "church." Among outsiders they are often called the "Local Church."
The Liite organization is totalist and all power is centralized in its headquarters, the Living Stream Ministry (LSM) of 2431 W La Palma Avenue, Anaheim, California. The LSM runs its own publishing operation and maintains tight control of subsidiaries throughout the world called "local churches." The LSM enforces a strict monopoly of all printed and recorded materials for sale and for use in worship. The LSM also closely supervises all religious doctrines and rituals through control of regional and local leadership, through periodic mass meetings called "conferences," through periodic and year-round indoctrination camps called "trainings," and by enforcing mandatory tax-deductible donations from members and distribution outlets.
Although Liites cherish their secrecy, they can easily find other distribution outlets by looking in a phone book for "The Church in" followed by the name of a major city.
Posted by
Good Christian Boy
at
19:02
Labels: Doctrine, Who are the Liites?